Episode 22 · The Search Signal · A Victorious Podcast
About this episode
Are you building your 2027 plan the old way, with search engine optimization (SEO) and public relations (PR) in separate budgets under separate owners and website content owned by yet another team? Leadership has probably already flagged that AI answers matter, but it's rarely clear which of those teams should own getting them right or how to prove the work is paying off. Buyers who used to compare a handful of websites and their reviews now ask ChatGPT or Google's AI Mode which company to go with. They get back one answer, built from that company's own site and from what other sites say about it. That answer draws on the work of all three teams.
In the second of three episodes on how to plan for search in 2027, Michael Transon makes the case for running SEO, content, and PR as one program aimed at the same handful of AI answers and measured by visibility and conversions. Watch to hear the five parts of that plan in the order he'd tackle them, including why pages that repackage what already ranks no longer earn AI citations and why PR and off-page SEO belong in one plan.
Michael's POV in 60 seconds
One thing
Marketing leaders are heading into 2027 planning with SEO and PR sitting in separate budgets, often under separate owners, and website content owned by yet a third team. Buyers, meanwhile, are increasingly skipping the multi-site research process and asking ChatGPT or Google's AI Mode which company to go with, and getting back a single answer instead of a list of options to sort through themselves.
So what
That consolidated answer gets built from what the company's own site says and from what other sites say about it, so the SEO budget and the PR budget end up aimed at the same target whether anyone planned it that way or not. The traffic each one used to generate stops being the measure that matters, because by the time a buyer reaches the site they've often already been influenced somewhere else.
Now what
Run this as one search program instead of five separate initiatives. Pick the subjects the company wants to own and build one buyer-language question list from them, keep the site technically sound, invest in non-commodity content, bring PR and off-page SEO together under one off-site plan, and set targets on visibility and conversions that get reported together instead of channel by channel.
Questions this episode answers
How do I decide what my company should be known for and turn that into a question list?
Start by deciding what your company wants to be known for in 2027, choosing a short list of subjects your company can be the best at and that also drive revenue, since every subject you add spreads a limited budget thinner. From there, build the actual questions buyers ask in their own words, pulled from sales call recordings, support tickets, forums, and Google's related questions, covering both what people ask while they're still learning and the commercial questions they ask once they're picking a company.
How do I know which existing content to keep, fix, or retire before creating anything new?
Start with the content you already have. Go through your pages against the subjects and questions you want to own, and decide which to keep, improve, combine, or retire. Before cutting anything, check whether an AI tool is citing it, since citation influence doesn't always line up with how a page performs in traditional traffic. Only once that audit is done should you create anything new, and it has to be something only your company could write, like your own data, case studies, or an expert's POV, because AI tools already build the complete version of a page themselves and have no reason to cite another one.
How do I combine PR and off-page SEO into one plan?
Build one list of in-house experts who can speak on your subjects and one consistent company description, and have both the SEO and PR sides draw from it instead of working from separate materials. Run your buyer-question list through each AI tool your buyers use, see which sites keep showing up as sources, and start with the ones you control directly, like directory profiles and competitor roundup lists, before handing publications and journalist outreach to PR. Whichever team does the outreach, the sites being cited have to be independent and real, since AI tools are getting better at spotting fake accounts, invented authors, and planted content.
Sound bites
Search is becoming the fastest growing and the most influential channel a lot of companies have. And at the same time, it is becoming the one that they can track the least.
Michael Transon
What I want to know at the end of the day is whether we're showing up more and whether conversions are strong, which is the front and the back of the pipeline. Traffic sits between those two things.
Michael Transon
Chapters
Why 2027 Buying Decisions Are Consolidating Into AI Answers
Decide What Your Company Wants to Be Known For
Describe Your Brand Consistently Everywhere You Control
Build Your Question List From Real Buyer Language
Run Your Questions and Pick Which AI Tools to Prioritize
Keep Your Site Technically Sound for AI Search
Make Sure AI Crawlers Can Actually Access Your Site
Write Clear, Consistent Descriptions on Every Key Page
Invest in Authoritative, Non-Commoditized Content
Audit Existing Content Before Creating Anything New
Why Skyscraper Content No Longer Earns AI Citations
The 2026 Content Pendulum: From Overproduction to Giving Up
Merge PR and Off-Page SEO Into One Off-Site Plan
Run Your Question List Through Every AI Tool to Find Citations
Keep Citations and Mentions Real, Never Fake
Set 2027 Goals on Visibility and Conversions, Not Traffic
Ask Buyers How They Actually Heard About You
Report Visibility, Conversions, and Content Together
Resources mentioned
Take this further
Don't miss an episode
New episodes every week. Get them in your podcast app of choice, or watch on YouTube.
Full transcript
Michael 00:00 – 00:50
Unless something changes, your traffic is probably gonna go down next year. And that can be okay. If your conversions can go up at the same time, and if you're doing a good job influencing buyers in these new search surfaces and tools. The reason is because by the time these buyers go to your website, they have already been influenced somewhere else. And most of what's been published on this shows that people who come from AI tools tend to convert at a much higher rate than people who come from other channels, including regular search.
Michael 00:50 – 01:24
Hey, welcome back to The Search Signal. I am Michael Transon. I'm the founder and CEO of a search marketing agency called Victorious. And here at The Search Signal, our goal is to help marketers understand and also take action on what is happening in the very quickly moving world of search marketing. So we've been running campaigns ourselves for nearly 13 years. We work with some of the biggest and also some of the fastest growing brands that are out there in the market today. So we take what we learn from those experiences with those clients, plus a lot of our own first party data and research here into The Search Signal to help you with your own work.
Michael 01:24 – 01:55
Now, this is the second of three episodes on how to plan for search for your business in 2027. Last episode we spent some time looking back at what had changed this year. And the biggest change, in my opinion, is that clicks stopped being a required part about how people decide who to buy from. Um, And it's because buyers got a lot more comfortable choosing a company based on what an AI tool or AI surface had told them. So that episode is about what you should do about that in 2027.
Michael 01:55 – 02:41
And then we're gonna talk about that today as well. And then in the next episode, we're gonna get into how to actually do that. And what I mean by that is who's gonna be doing the work on your team, how do you find those people, and then also how to budget for it. So if you are a marketing leader and you're putting your 2027 plan together right now, there is a pretty good chance that your SEO and your PR are currently sitting in uh separate budgets and probably with some separate owners on the team. And also on top of that, your content might also be sitting somewhere else again, like your website content, who owns that. Um, You've also probably been told that AI answers are important and they matter for you and for your leadership, but it's not always obvious which of those teams should own that.
Michael 02:41 – 03:37
Or also how you show leadership that the teams that own it are doing a good job and it's working. So the way that I think about next year, 2027, is that uh the decisions about who to buy from uh in the market are consolidating into uh, I would say a handful of AI answers. And as we've talked about here before, those answers get built from what's not only on your own website, but also what other people are publishing about you and saying about you. So the plan we'll talk about today and what I'd recommend uh treats search as we've talked about prior as just one unified program where the work on your site and the work of getting other sites to talk about you are meant to be aimed at performing in the same answers and where you judge all of it by your visibility and also by your conversions.
Michael 03:37 – 04:16
Instead of historically, what we've been tracking, which is the traffic that this channel sends to your website. So I'm going to start with why these decisions that are happening in the market, how people choose to buy things are consolidating. And then I'm going to spend the rest of the episode on five things that I would recommend you think about for your plans for 2027. Also, I'm going to give you the order in which I would recommend doing them. So let's dive in. A few years ago, if you were in the market trying to pick a company to work with for, whatever, um, you'd probably start by searching on Google.
Michael 04:16 – 04:57
Um, You might click through a bunch of websites, uh, read reviews, ask a couple people you trust, and then you would make that decision uh yourself. Now, a lot of buyers are asking ChatGPT or uh Google's AI Mode what company they should go with. And they get one answer back for that. So what's happening is search is getting bigger and it's getting smaller and it's happening at the same time. Uh, It can look like a lot more uh competition because, as you know, a couple of years ago, Google was really the only place where people searched.
Michael 04:57 – 05:31
But now you've got ChatGPT and Claude and some other things like Perplexity. But each of those tools do the same thing, which it gives a prospective buyer of yours just one answer and they pull it from a group of sources. And what that means is what used to be a thousand different paths to a decision from a bunch of different competitor websites and review sites and recommended sites and other uh owned properties helping to influence decisions is getting narrowed down to just a couple of AI consolidated answers.
Michael 05:31 – 06:15
And when a buyer is still learning about a problem, and they're earlier in their journey, a lot of what AI tools cite um come from companies' own websites. We talked about this in our last quarterly search report that came out last month. And uh what we had found was that company websites, like your own website, made up a little over half of all the citations, which are uh other websites that are being used to formulate an answer in early research questions. And then when buyers get to the point of asking which company that they want to pick, a lot of those answers of who to work with come from what other websites say about companies in that specific industry or category.
Michael 06:15 – 06:56
So it'd be like news coverage, industry publications. There's a lot of websites out there with lists of top providers pretty much in every category. Um, Also review forums like Reddit and such. Um, What us marketers call that is earned media. Um, Some of those placements are paid, some of them aren't, but for the purpose of this conversation, that really doesn't change much because the point is either way, those companies and those other websites are talking about you and your competitors and being used for the answer. So the answer about your company is getting built from your own site and from everybody else's. And your 2027 plan for search has to be able to cover both.
Michael 06:56 – 07:28
So we have to start by deciding what we want to be known for and then build a list or strategy of questions and answers we want to show up in from that. The first thing that I would personally uh recommend is to build that list in a cohesive way in which your entire search program can run from PR included and start by deciding what you want your company to be known for in 2027. AI tools answer questions on a question by question format.
Michael 07:28 – 08:01
So because of that, the only way to see what your buyers see is to ask the same questions that they ask and also just look what comes back. And um, you can't pick those questions until you actually know what subjects you want to own. And it can't be everything. You really should start with a shorter list of subjects. We did an episode about this, gosh, it was probably in September of this year. Um, And we talked about building uh brand entity. And the way that I said to think about this is to pick things that your company can be the best at that also can drive your revenue.
Michael 08:01 – 08:41
And I still recommend keeping that list short because we talked about this. The AI tools tend to connect a company with the subjects that they keep seeing it uh next to its name. And when you've got a limited budget, every subject that you add is going to mean fewer places where that shows up next year is 'cause you're spreading yourself um thin. So uh after we've done that, I would recommend we then describe those things that we want to be known as the same way everywhere we can control. So it's your website, your directory profiles, any owned media profiles, any places where you have the ability to use your own words to describe what your brand is about.
Michael 08:41 – 09:16
When we're thinking about putting together a plan for 2027 and establishing these entities, we wanna be very, very consistent. So once we've been consistent and we know the things that we want to be uh known for in AI search, we then have to build the questions for each of those subject areas from what we would think are the words that our buyers use, which if you have a sales team, you can hear those in call recordings, or if you've got a support team, what they get asked. You can also do some external research, look at what people post in forums, or um, also Google's very helpful here.
Michael 09:16 – 09:47
You can actually look at related questions that Google shows up in its results. Um, We want to also cover the questions that people ask while they're still learning about a problem. And then on top of that, of course, the commercial ones, the ones that they actually ask when they're thinking about picking a company. And this could be, you know, 10 questions per subject. It could be 50 questions. It really just depends on how broad. you want to go as a company. Um, Then we want to start running those questions as samples.
Michael 09:47 – 10:29
And there are a lot of tools out there that you can use a lot of AI tracking and visibility tools to upload questions. And then you can set how often you want those questions to be run uh every couple of days, every week, every few weeks. And then also on what LLMs you want to be performing in. We had a whole episode where we talked about how to decide if you should be prioritizing Google surfaces versus ChatGPT versus Claude based off of the type of business you are and the types of buyers you sell to. And in that episode, I did say that I believe that Google's search surfaces are the priority for the majority of businesses with ChatGPT the second.
Michael 10:29 – 11:20
So once you've got that set up, you can start seeing how those runs will return responses. And the reason why we want to run them regularly is because no two uh questions see the same answers. And these lists or these responses that we get can work and be helpful for us as bellwethers that show which way things are moving for us. And what's helpful, I said this earlier, we want a cohesive approach for 2027. And we'll talk a little bit more about why that is uh as we talk a little bit more today. But when every team, SEO content, PR, plans from the same list, the content you publish and the sites that you go after for citations are all aimed at the same answers. And it's really helpful because then you can see whether that work is moving those answers or not.
Michael 11:20 – 12:02
uh And before any of your content can show up for those questions and your company show up in those responses, we have to make sure that we go back to first principles too. We have to make sure that the AI tools and the search engines can actually read and understand what your site is about. So the second thing that I would recommend is something that we have always said in the SEO world and is still very, very true today. We have to keep our site technically sound because that is absolutely still the core work, the core SEO work and everything else in a search plan, a good modern search plan is going to sit on top of that.
Michael 12:02 – 12:35
We did a whole episode on technical SEO and AI search earlier this fall. And honestly, the short version of that is that the differences between traditional search and AI search are a lot smaller than the big voices in the industry make them sound. And you should be continually doing the technical work on the website you have always done. And I would absolutely not defer or minimize this.
Michael 12:35 – 13:18
So that you can use more budget to pay for things like uh mention building or AI search work that is unique to AI search because one of the most important things is Google's AI features, which I just said I think are the most important surfaces for most businesses, they pull from Google's regular index. And we know Google's regular index prioritizes technical SEO health. So this means making sure that search engines can crawl and can index the pages that we care about, especially the pages associated with the things that we want to be known for in search, and that your structured data is correct.
Michael 13:18 – 14:06
And it also means we want to still protect our traditional search rankings, even in 2027. Uh, In that search report that we published last month, we also found that more than a third of what Google AI Overviews, which is an AI search surface, uh, cited from came from pages that were already ranking in the top 10 for in Google for that same search. So what that infers is that ranking well in traditional search still does a lot of work for us in being performant in Google's new and evolving AI search surfaces. So once we have done that, we then need to make sure from a technical health perspective, that the AI tools can also get in and can figure out who you are.
Michael 14:06 – 14:40
We've talked about this before. Uh, But for example, we need to make sure that robots, our robots file and our firewall are not blocking the various different types of crawlers that AI search tools use, from the bots that are there to train the models to the bots there that are able to fetch live data using web searches. We also need to make sure that each important page on the website very clearly says what our company does in plain text, very close to the top, because that's the first thing that these bots see.
Michael 14:40 – 15:15
And using that same description that we had talked about in the first step. On top of this, very practical advice: your homepage and your about page should say very clearly what you sell and who you sell to. And the structured data that we just talked about on your site should describe your company in the same exact way. So the point being is whenever a human or whenever a machine, a bot, is reading our website, it comes away with a very clear, single, consistent description of our company. Because a technically sound website is going to get you uh indexed and read.
Michael 15:15 – 15:53
But what gets you cited is the next thing that I want to talk to you about, which is the actual content that you are researching, drafting, and publishing on that website. So the third thing that I would recommend as you think about planning for your 2027 is I strongly, strongly recommend that you keep investing in authoritative, non-commoditized, non-AI slop content on your own site because we know for a fact that is what earns citations. And we also know that citations lead to a 2x growth in actual mentions and in recommendations.
Michael 15:53 – 16:28
When someone asks an AI tool who to work with. So in our report, our search report this last quarter, the brands whose content got cited on these early research questions, like I said, were named almost twice as often. That's a huge improvement. Named twice as often when people were asking which company that they were gonna pick. So if you do not have strong, unique, authoritative content that is on your site that AI tools want and are hungry for citing, you are going to have a harder time showing up when buyers start to pivot and ask who they should work with.
Michael 16:28 – 17:01
So my recommendation as we think about 2027, we want to start with the content that you already have going into January. All right. So I would say go through your pages against the subjects that we want to be known for and the question list that we developed around those subjects that we want to show up for. And we can decide which ones to keep. Which ones to improve, which to combine with another page on the same topic. Or there might be pages on the site that we want to retire because they are about something that we might not want to be known for.
Michael 17:01 – 17:33
And I would strongly recommend you think about improving what you have before you think about creating anything new. Now, as it relates to retiring content, when you're deciding what you want to cut. We need to check to make sure that an AI tool uh is or is not citing a page before we remove it . And I know this is a part that I find personally frustrating. I know our content team at Victorious has found this too, because we used to judge the performance and quality of a page and whether it should stay or go by its traffic.
Michael 17:33 – 18:06
That worked when traffic was most of what a page did for a website. Now though, most of the influential pages on a website, you know, the ones that AI tools pull from when buyers are asking about you, those could theoretically be some of your worst performing pages in traditional search and in traffic. And there's really not a super clean way to measure that kind of influence right now outside of looking at is this page being cited? Is it being used to formulate answers? But once you have done that with existing content, then and only then would I recommend in 2027, you put new effort into new content.
Michael 18:06 – 18:37
And we should focus on, like I said earlier, non-commoditized, unique content and a POV that you believe only your company has the experience and ability to say. So for a lot of time uh to perform in search, uh a lot of content got strategized and built with what people call, if you haven't heard this before, the skyscraper approach. And this is where you find a page that is ranking for a topic in search. You take the best parts of each of the top results and then you publish just a bigger, more complete version of this.
Michael 18:37 – 19:18
Um Here's the thing. That's basically what an AI answer does now. So a page that gets built that way ends up as a, in my opinion, a weaker duplicate or version of the answer that the buyer is already getting in AI. And so AI tools have no reason to cite skyscraper content because they're building it themselves. They actually want source content. We did a whole full funnel series on AI search this summer, and I talked about a very simple test for this, which you just take your content and you just like take it off your website, put it on like a word doc, and you can look and say, if I read this and I took my company's name out, would anybody notice that it doesn't fit my business?
Michael 19:18 – 19:53
Is there anything unique about this that my competitors wouldn't be able to write about themselves because they don't have that? These would be like your own data or case studies with results that you got from those case studies. if possible, original research or a POV from experts at your company that are doing the work on a day-to-day basis and including things like their background and information about them so the machines can actually validate who they are. The AI tools, we know for a fact, have started citing more government sites and industry association sites, with those early types of questions.
Michael 19:53 – 20:26
And our page topic should be specific and helpful and research driven enough to outperform government sites and industry association sites. And we can only do that by putting non-commoditized high quality content out there. I know that content has been a topic of contention in 2026, to put it lightly. There were times in 2026 where people were going crazy, publishing hundreds of pieces of content a month.
Michael 20:26 – 20:58
And they thought that this was a way to scale their organic traffic. And then the year went on and sites started getting de-indexed and penalized. The scaled content abuse penalty came out. Uh, And then they started realizing that that generic commoditized content wasn't ranking and it wasn't showing up in citations. And there was a hard pivot that happened in 2026 where people started to think that, well, maybe I shouldn't be publishing content at all. My organic traffic is going down.
Michael 20:58 – 21:30
Blog posts that I'm publishing aren't generating the same amount of traffic that they have historically. AI answers are stealing traffic by formulating their own answers. And uh what I am saying is going into 2027, I want us to find the middle. Creating commoditized, crappy content is a poor way to build a brand. And we know for a fact that it doesn't create improvements in citations and it doesn't create improvements in mentions in AI answers.
Michael 21:30 – 22:04
It doesn't create improvements in performance in Google rankings and traditional SERP results. But we do know what does. And it is the high quality content that humans have culpability in and are participating in that are unique and feed these systems with a POV that helps them formulate better answers to users. So we'll talk about this in our next episode on how to plan out your content approach and how to resource it.
Michael 22:04 – 22:35
But There are three options. Either produce a ton of low quality content, produce no content, and produce a select amount of high quality content. And I would strongly recommend you consider the third option because we have seen time and time again in our research that that will yield strong brand outcomes and performance both in traditional SERPs and in AI search surfaces. So your own content is going to get you cited ah while your buyers are.
Michael 22:35 – 23:20
learning about uh your industry and trying to gather top of the funnel information. But what other websites say about you carries a whole lot more when determining who actually gets mentioned and recommended. And let's talk about that next. So the fourth thing that I would recommend for you in 2027 as you're planning out your search strategy and your budget is to build plans to create more authority off of your website by bringing PR and the off-site side of your SEO into one cohesive plan. Now the off-page side of SEO is the work of getting other websites to mention and to link to your website.
Michael 23:20 – 23:58
And in our last search report, the number of sites that mention a brand and the number that link to it were what predicted which brands the AI tool named more than anything else. So this is still what I would call authority building. And it's also still core SEO work. But let's talk about how it relates to PR, because PR and SEO grew up as separate teams. And that was because they had influence different things in different ways and you could track them in different ways. Uh PR got your company into, you know, publications that your uh that your buyers are reading.
Michael 23:58 – 24:42
And, you know, from a reporting perspective, you mostly just showed leadership. Hey, we got this article and we got this placement. And then SEO's off page work got you links and mentions so that you would rank in Google where SEO could track all the clicks. So both of those reasons for keeping them separate, in my opinion, are going away. The reason is the publications PR has always gone after are losing a ton of traffic. And it's the same reason why clicks are down for everybody else. So more of what a placement now, a PR placement, does for you, depends on whether the AI tools are gonna read it and also repeat it. Um, Also, PR can now check, which is a good thing, whether its coverage is gonna show up as a source in AI answers.
Michael 24:42 – 25:32
On the flip side, SEO is actually getting harder to measure because of the click issue, right? Clicks are no longer required. So the two, in my opinion, are meeting in the middle of measurement. So at Victorious, we call our side of it mention building, which is that work that we're doing on getting uh a company named alongside the subjects that they want to be known for and on the sites that we know AI tools and search engines are actively reading and using. PR is often about um image and the prestige of a really well-known publication. And then mention building that we do is a lot more, I would call pragmatic, uh, because it's just simply going after whatever sites the AI tools are reading. And it also includes things like top provider lists and industry directories. So, in my opinion, what I would recommend is you should start in 2027 by building one source of expertise that both of these teams are going to draw from.
Michael 25:32 – 26:03
Uh, The original research we talked about. And the expert POV in your content that we talked about building for your own site are the same exact things journalists and these people who write for these top provider lists are looking for. So we can keep a list of people inside of our company that can speak on subjects, and then we can use the description of our company everywhere it shows up. And then our goal is to get both of these teams working at the sites that the AI tools cite for your question lists, which is what we call at Victorious citation building.
Michael 26:03 – 26:47
So you run that question list through each of the tools that your buyer uses, We talked about this earlier. You can use an AI tracking tool to see what ChatGPT, AI Mode, all these different tools Claude says about you. And we keep track of the sites that are being used and get cited in the answers. And we want to separate them by tool. And we can start by looking at the things that we have control over that we can change ourselves. If we're getting directories, directory profiles are being cited in answers. If we're getting free profiles, if we're getting competitor roundup lists that we can sign up for, those are great things that are in our control that we can use to create more citations for our business. And that's citation and mention building at its core.
Michael 26:47 – 27:25
Then on top of that, we have publications that might be cited. We might have news articles that might be cited. We might have third-party review sites that are roundups that are being cited. Those are publications and journalists that can be integrated between PR and SEO. And ideally, I would say this: if you have a partner, and Victorious does this, but if you have a partner that can do both. Can do the PR side of reaching out to publications, reaching out to uh publishers and getting inclusion into content, as well as the pragmatic versions of citation building and mention building.
Michael 27:25 – 28:10
That's an ideal way to go about this. But if you also have two teams, that's also fine as well. The PR team can handle journalists and publications and they can be doing their outreach. And, they could be connecting with these companies and these websites. Now, some of the people who run these lists will also just Just so we're clear, they're gonna ask for things like payment, or they might ask for things like link exchanges to include you. We'll talk about that in the next episode and about how to plan for that in your budget. Um, But the other thing I would say is uh it's really important that we make sure that these websites that we are looking to get citations or brand mentions on or PR placements on are independent of us and they are coming from people who are real.
Michael 28:10 – 28:51
No fake accounts, no uh invented authors or planted reviews. We've talked about this before, but the AI systems are getting better at tracking what's fake and what's real. And they're also uh putting the hammer down on companies that participate in uh deceptive content. So we want to make sure that what we are reaching out to is real people. We're not doing things like creating fake websites that are recommending us against our competitors and making it seem like it's some independent company that's talking about us. We need to make sure that we are reaching out to legitimate third party sites and working on link exchanges and getting our placements on those platforms.
Michael 28:51 – 29:23
Okay, now that we've talked about as we think about 2027's plans for search, what work needs to be done off of the website, let's talk about how we can judge in 2027 whether any of this work is actually working. So the fifth thing I would recommend, and you probably already do this, but just to be clear, is we need to start planning our 2027 search goals on visibility and conversions. Now, here's the kicker for 2027 versus 2026.
Michael 29:23 – 29:55
I would not necessarily recommend you plan your KPIs and your goals for 2027 as it relates to search on traffic growth. And the reason why I say that, in my opinion, search is becoming the fastest growing and the most influential channel a lot of companies have. And at the same time, it is becoming the one that they can track the least. And I think a lot of marketers are gonna have to get comfortable with that.
Michael 29:55 – 30:34
Unless something changes, your traffic is probably gonna go down next year. And that can be okay. If your conversions can go up at the same time, and if you're doing a good job influencing buyers in these new search surfaces and tools. The reason is because by the time these buyers go to your website, they have already been influenced somewhere else. And most of what's been published on this shows that people who come from AI tools tend to convert at a much higher rate than people who come from other channels, including regular search.
Michael 30:34 – 31:07
So this would be a big change for how most businesses track whether search is working for literally the entire existence of SEO. We have seen traffic as one of the primary KPI metrics. And in 2027, your traffic can go down. And it could go down significantly. And the channel could be performant. So it's really important that you agree with your leadership on how search gets judged before this year starts.
Michael 31:07 – 31:50
Um, Me, I'm a CEO and we have a search campaign and search program at Victorious for ourselves. What I want to know at the end of the day is whether we're showing up more and whether conversions are strong, which is the front and the back of the pipeline. Traffic sits between those two things. And the way that I've been seeing it is. I have to treat it like a vanity metric because honestly, traffic was only really ever there to get someone to the point of buying or to become a lead. So if that's true, we set our visibility targets on how often we are named in AI tools and the questions we want to be uh showing up for based off that list that we talked about building, and how many people are searching our company by name.
Michael 31:50 – 32:22
Branded search is a great thing to look at. And then conversion targets on leads and on sales. I would still keep traffic on whatever scorecard you use, I would still keep it next to there because it will still show where people are coming in. But it is, in my opinion, not the primary thing we need to be looking at. And then another important KPI to track, which is more manual than we have done historically, but I strongly recommend this, is to actually ask your buyers to answer a question of how they heard about you.
Michael 32:22 – 33:25
Um The reason is because when influence works in AI, the credit for that influence oftentimes shows up somewhere else. Somebody might look and hear about you in an AI answer. And again, you won't be able to know that because you can't see the actual conversation between your prospective buyer and the AI tool. Um, And then after that, they might come in through organic search. They might search your company by brand name, or they might come in through an AI referral. They might click on a link that ChatGPT might offer them. To go to your website. Or they might click on ChatGPT and ChatGPT might not send a referral tag. So it might plop itself into direct traffic and not AI referral traffic. Right now, the most reliable way to uh figure out how somebody came to your website, but also how they were primarily influenced to work with you and reach out, is to ask them. And I would recommend doing this on forms on your website.
Michael 33:25 – 34:02
If you do use lead capture forms, how did you hear about us? And as a backup on sales calls. They were probably influenced in more than one place, to be honest. But they'll tell you the one that mattered the most to them. We talked about setting this up in episode 20, if you want to go back and listen to that one. Once we've done that, We need to report the work and the results together, putting our new content, PR placements, new mentions that we get from other websites, new citations from other websites into the same report where we are tracking our visibility and our conversions.
Michael 34:02 – 34:34
And along with that, what the new leads are saying when you ask them how they heard about you. And what you can do is you can line up a story and a narrative for leadership on a month to month, quarter by quarter basis where you are seeing you could see visibility increase as a result of new mentions and new citations as a result of publishing high quality content. And that visibility is rewarded with an increase in branded search. It might be associated with an increase in direct traffic.
Michael 34:34 – 35:11
There might be a moderate increase in AI referral traffic. You might see a drop in organic search because the platform's being used less. And you might see an increase in conversion rate across direct traffic and AI referral traffic and maybe even organic search, because, like we said, these buyers are more significantly influenced and further into their purchase journey when they get to your website, increasing the percentage of those uh visitors who will ultimately convert by transacting or reaching out and submitting a lead form to talk to sales.
Michael 35:11 – 35:51
So we're gonna get into all of the minutiae of how to set up a team, how to set up a budget, where you should be putting your budget, how you should be setting up your KPIs, how you should be setting up your goals, how to track them, all in the next episode. It's gonna be very, very, very practical. I'm gonna do my best to keep it as helpful for as many listeners as possible because we have a lot of different listeners from a lot of different types of businesses. But as we look at 2027, the decisions that we talked about today are about how purchasing is being consolidated in 2027 into fewer AI answers.
Michael 35:51 – 36:28
And those answers are going to be built from both what your website has in terms of authoritative content and also what other websites are publishing and saying about you. What I would recommend is decide what you want your business to be known for in search. And like we talked about, build a list. And strategy of questions from that. We need to keep our site technically sound and clear about who we are. We need to absolutely continue to invest in content about things only your company can provide a POV on in terms of data, case studies, research, and experts.
Michael 36:28 – 36:58
And then I would strongly recommend bringing PR and off-page SEO together, marry them into one cohesive off-site plan aimed at the sites that AI tools are citing. And when we were talking about reporting, we want to set our goals on visibility and conversions while we report on the work and the results together in one cohesive format. So next episode, we're going to get into how to do all of this. Like I said, who should own which piece, how much I would generally recommend that you spend on all of this.
Michael 36:58 – 37:30
We're going to give some general recommendations based off of how much revenue your business does, what should be spent here. And I'll also give some recommendations based off of if you spend money on paid media or search ads or PPC, what's a healthy percentage to invest into building your brand? And we'll talk about the split between investing in your brand in the long term, which is what we are talking about here, versus the short-term dopamine hit that can be good from paid search and how to make sure that those are complementing each other so that we are not over-indexed on one side or the other.
Michael 37:30 – 37:47
So that's today's episode on what to do in search in 2027 as we think about next year. Let's say thank you for listening to this week's episode of The Search Signal. If this was useful for you, uh please go ahead and subscribe so the next episode finds you wherever you are. That is it for me this week. I will see you for episode three next week.