AEO Guide: Communication
Getting Buy-In for AEO When Success Is Hard To Measure
You understand AEO strategy and measurement principles. Now you need stakeholders to commit resources and test approaches that use new success indicators.
In This Article
Additional Resources
Traditional SEO gave marketers a clear framework for building internal support: show ranking improvements, demonstrate traffic growth, and connect organic sessions to revenue. AEO doesn’t work that way. Citations don’t always drive clicks. Branded search lift doesn’t appear in attribution reports. Even successful experiments often raise more questions than they answer.
Engaging in answer engine optimization requires a certain degree of comfort with iteration and experimentation because we still don’t have irrefutable ways to measure success. You might find yourself in the position of asking stakeholders to support testing cycles that don’t have concrete outcomes.
The challenge isn’t convincing stakeholders that AI search matters but maintaining confidence in your approach while navigating genuine uncertainty about what works, how to measure it, and when results will appear. But how do you do that when AEO skeptics curb or resist your efforts?
Build Early Momentum With Willing Partners
The most effective way to build internal support for AEO is through small wins that demonstrate value that directly relates to stakeholder goals.
Start With the Willing
Identify stakeholders who are already frustrated with the downstream implications of poor search visibility or content performance. These early adopters become your testing partners and internal proof points.
Look for people who’ve expressed concerns like:
- Strong content losing traction over time.
- Competitors gaining visibility in places where your brand should appear.
- A shrinking lead pipeline from organic traffic.
When a content manager mentions their best-performing articles aren’t driving the traffic they used to, that’s an opening to test AEO formatting on a few key pieces.
When a marketing director notes that competitors seem to be getting more brand mentions despite lower domain authority, that’s a chance to test citation optimization.
If an inbound manager is feeling the pinch of over reliance on paid search, that’s a chance to look for early signs of direct or branded traffic lift.
Create Low-Risk Proof Points
To garner support, design initial AEO tests that require minimal investment but might generate visible results. For example, rather than suggesting the content team restructure an entire content library, suggest specific experiments, like:
- Reformatting five high-traffic pages with AEO principles. Then track citation rates over 30 days.
- Adding structured FAQ sections to three cornerstone pieces and monitoring AI visibility for related queries.
- Optimizing author credentials on existing thought leadership content and measuring branded search lift.
- Testing different answer formats (concise vs. comprehensive) on informational pages.
The goal here is to demonstrate that a test-and-learn approach to optimization can create measurable improvements. When skeptics see structured experimentation producing results, they’ll be more open to investing in scaled AEO efforts.
Convert Skeptics Into Advocates
Once you have early proof points, use them to engage stakeholders who were initially resistant.
Document Everything
Skeptics can become advocates when they see consistent evidence of thoughtful decision-making and honest reporting. To earn their confidence, maintain detailed records of AEO experiments, including:
- Hypothesis: What you expected to happen and why.
- Methodology: Specific changes, when they were made, and how results were measured.
- Results: What actually happened, including unexpected outcomes.
- Implications: What this teaches you about your next set of tests.
Keeping and sharing records of your AEO tests allows stakeholders to review your decision-making process and see that you’re learning from both successes and failures. When you demonstrate this discipline consistently, occasional failures could actually strengthen confidence in your overall approach. This transparency builds credibility that extends beyond any single test result.
Make Skeptics Part of the Solution
Transform opposition into collaboration by asking resistant stakeholders to help design tests that would convince them.
SEO
When SEOs dismiss AEO as unnecessary or premature:
- Show competitive examples of who’s getting cited in AI overviews for your key topics.
- Share specific differences between traditional ranking signals and AI retrieval patterns.
- Collaborate on tests that would convince them that AEO requires some distinct tactics beyond standard SEO.
Web Devs
When web developers question implementation feasibility:
- Have them audit proposed schema markup or structural changes.
- Ask them to flag which elements create maintenance burdens versus one-time builds.
- Use their constraints to prioritize high-impact, low-effort optimizations.
Content
When content team members worry about workflow disruption:
- Test formatting changes on a few articles first and gather feedback.
- Identify which adjustments fit naturally into existing processes and which feel forced.
- Collaborate on templates and checklists that integrate with existing editorial processes.
Finance
When they question ROI potential:
- Acknowledge that direct attribution is more complex than traditional SEO.
- Position AEO as a way to protect the value of previous content investments as search changes influence user behavior.
This approach ensures your tests address real concerns rather than imagined ones, and it gives former skeptics ownership in AEO success. People support what they help create.
How To Maintain Stakeholder Confidence During Setbacks
AEO measurement presents unique challenges that you don’t face with traditional SEO metrics: citations can be volatile, personalization will skew results, and the delay between improved visibility and the downstream impact can extend for weeks.
All this means that even well-designed AEO experiments will sometimes produce unclear or disappointing results. How you handle these ambiguous outcomes determines whether stakeholders view you as a thoughtful strategist adapting to new challenges or as someone chasing trends without clear direction.
Turn Failed Tests Into Strategic Intelligence
When an AEO experiment doesn’t produce expected citation increases or visibility improvements, position the outcome as valuable data rather than wasted effort. Every result contributes to a larger understanding of how AEO works (or doesn’t) in your specific context.
For example, if restructuring product pages with AEO formatting doesn’t increase citations after 30 days, that teaches you something important about how AI systems evaluate commercial content versus informational content. This insight helps refine further testing and saves you from pursuing an approach that doesn’t work for that content type.
When you share failed experiments with leadership, explain how the results will inform your next round of testing. If FAQ schema doesn’t improve citation rates but pages with strong internal linking gain visibility, shift your next experiments toward topical clustering. This shows that even when tests don’t deliver the expected results, they can still move the strategy forward.
Maintain Credibility Through Honest Assessment
When experiments fail, resist the temptation to oversell partial successes or blame external factors. Acknowledge lackluster results directly, then focus on what you learned and how that informs better experiments.
Stakeholders trust leaders who can honestly assess setbacks and adjust strategy accordingly. When you demonstrate that discipline consistently, occasional failures can strengthen confidence in your overall approach.
Evolve Tactics Without Abandoning Strategy
Changing AEO tactics based on test results isn’t the same as abandoning AEO strategy. Help stakeholders understand the difference between tactical adjustments and strategic retreats.
When initial experiments with content restructuring don’t produce citation increases, shifting focus to technical optimization or author credibility signals represents strategic evolution, not failure. Frame these pivots as evidence that you’re learning faster than competitors and adapting your approach based on real data rather than assumptions.
Keep Experimenting
AEO success comes from building the organizational capacity to test, learn, and adapt faster than your competitors.Â
When you’ve established transparent documentation practices, collaborative testing frameworks, and honest communication about setbacks, you’ve built more than stakeholder buy-in. You’ve created the organizational agility to transform the current uncertainty about AI visibility from a potential liability into a strategic advantage.
Director of Brand Growth
Jill Maldonado helps shape how Victorious approaches growth. Her work spans strategy, storytelling, and creative direction, with an emphasis on how visibility and demand shape brand perception at the system level.
Updated Jan 12, 2026
Continue Your AEO Journey
Show up everywhere
your
audience searches.
Increase brand awareness and engagement with a custom SEO and AEO strategy that puts you in front of prospects wherever they seek information.